10. PaperChef Non-Stick
Made of eucalyptus fiber, PaperChef Non-Stick (appx. $20) is stronger when wet than many other options. It doesn’t absorb oils, so it can be used for multiple batches of cookies, and the natural brown color makes for excellent presentation when packaging baked goods for gifts.
- Kosher certified
- 205 sq ft per roll
- Does not have a metal cutting edge
9. Reynolds Pan Lining
The double-sided Reynolds Pan Lining (around $24) is the perfect combination of parchment and foil. The aluminum makes it easy to mold to fit your baking dish, helping to hold its shape and contain any liquid or oil that accumulates while food is cooking.
- Three 30 sq ft rolls
- No need for grease or nonstick spray
- Cannot be used in the microwave
8. ChicWrap Culinary
The ChicWrap Culinary (about $22) comes in a reusable dispenser that can hold any 15-inch roll, and it’s much easier to use than the flimsy cardboard boxes that most brands are packaged in. Plus, the fun, colorful design makes it a great gift for your favorite baker.
- Slider makes cutting effortless
- Non-skid feet prevent shifting
- Included roll is only 20 feet
7. Kana Lifestyle Round Sheets
Cutting out your own circles to line cake tins is not only a pain, it’s wasteful, too. These Kana Lifestyle Round Sheets (about $11) are already the perfect shape, and they’re also great for Dutch ovens, cheesecake pans, and even tortilla presses.
- Waterproof and tear-resistant
- Available in 8- and 9-inch sizes
- Come in an airtight zip-top bag
6. Zenlogy Exact Fit
Cut to 12″ x 16″ for half sheet pans, Zenlogy Exact Fit (appx. $13) are coated with vegetable-grade silicone, making them biodegradable. They won’t burn or curl up during baking, and are also available in multiple other sizes for different types of bakeware.
- Oven-safe up to 450 degrees f
- Lie flat for compact storage
- Great price for 100 sheets
5. If You Care
For environmentally-conscious households, If You Care (around $15) is the perfect balance between convenience and responsibility. It’s coated with natural rubber for a nonstick finish, and it’s both biodegradable and compostable, so you can feel good about any method of disposal.
- Fsc-certified eco-friendly
- Unbleached and chlorine-free
- Comes as a pack of 2
4. Reynolds Cookie Sheets
Conveniently pre-cut to the perfect size for most baking pans, Reynolds Cookie Sheets make prep work a breeze. They’re also great for catching extra sprinkles and drips of icing when you’re decorating, for a quick and easy cleanup.
- Box includes 22 pieces
- Won’t curl or roll
- Prevent grease buildup
3. Beyond Gourmet Unbleached
Great for lining baking sheets, rolling out pie or pizza dough, and making pouches to steam fish and vegetables, Beyond Gourmet Unbleached (about $5) is naturally nonstick, so you’ll never have to fight to get your baked goods out of the pan.
- Fully biodegradable
- Water-based silicone coating
- Safe for microwave use
2. The Smart Baker Sheets
Pre-cut to just the right size for your cake tins, The Smart Baker Sheets (around $5) make lining pans a breeze. Plus, they have tabs on two sides that you can grab onto, so you won’t have to turn the pan upside down to remove your delicious treats.
- Choose from a variety of sizes
- Also available in rounds
- Some proceeds donated to charity
1. Kirkland Signature
If you bake frequently, consider the Kirkland Signature (around $11), which comes as a 205 sq ft roll that will last for months, or maybe even years. Its sturdy enough to be used multiple times, and the super sharp blades make for easy cutting.
- Lies flat after tearing
- Excellent value for the price
- Also available in multi-packs